Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette for A Night At The Opera Holiday 2014 Collection, Review, Swatch, Comparison & FOTD

It must be the worth thing ever to have a public holiday on Saturday. It is then two days of shopping break. Possible I can use it as rehabilitation if there wouldn't be internet... Hmmm...

I have already started to tell how excited I am to find it out that Guerlain's Holiday Collection theme is Russian Ballet and some of the items are named after Stravinsky's timeless compositions. I wished there would be Rites of Spring (my favorite) in the names but I believe since it is a Christmas collection, it wouldn't be so appropriate after all. Check out my previous post to see a lovely gloss named after Firebird, one of his early works. Today it is about Eyes and Blush Palette Petrouchka, named after the composition which is known to be the piece "Stravinsky become Stravinsky". It all makes sense that it is the center piece of the collection as well.



Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette



Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette comes in a compact which is similar to their limited edition blushes, such as Madame Rougit. It comes wrapped in a red bow, with Guerlain's logo on it. It is indicated inside the package that this can be used as a hair band. Inside the box there is a velvet pouch with pockets. Inside the pockets there is a mini red cheek brush and a sponge tipped applicator for eyes. I don't find them very useful unless you would like to touch up during the day.



Package content of Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette

Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette has two tiers, the top one has five eye shadow shades. They are embossed with Guerlain's name. It is composed of warm shimmery naturals which are very finely milled with buttery texture. Almost all of them apply beautifully on the lids, the lightest two shades being a little sheer. The gold shade has the worse color pay off but the darker shades are all very smooth and pigmented and makes it up for the gold one.


Top layer of Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette

The shades are as follows:

Top most: A warm ivory with shimmery finish.

2nd from top: A neutral gold with shimmery finish. This is the one which applies semi transparent and lack a bit of pigment.

Middle: A gorgeous mid-toned copper with shimmery finish. This shade was included also at Gueriain's 2012 and 2013 Palettes (comparisons are at the end of this post)

2nd from bottom: A deep warm brown with red undertones. I love this shade for the outer corner. If you have green eyes, you need this shade! *winks*

Bottom: A very deep natural brown with shimmery finish. This shade has the less shimmer compared to the others, which is great if you want to use it on the crease or for definition.



Swatch of eye shadows, Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette

The second tier of Petrouchka Palette has four different brush shades. I was a little skeptical since I know that Guerlain blushes doesn't swatch very well and they are rather hardly pressed. So was not the case with the Petrouchka blushes. All of the turned out to be smooth to touch and very pigmented. I also found the sizes of the pots large enough for application since I like using smaller brushes in general. The smaller ones can be easily used by a large eye shadow brush and bigger ones are perfect for mid-sized blush brushes (I used Suqqu cheek with these and it was perfect for the size).




Bottom layer of Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette

The shades are as follows:

Top left (small pan): Light cool pink with shimmer particles on a satin base

Top right (large pan): Mid-toned berry with satin to matte finish, this shade is so beautiful for fall and winter, it applies and blends beautifully.

Bottom right (large pan): Mid-toned red coral with satin to matte finish. Lightly applied to the apples of the cheeks, it gives a wonderful natural flush.

Bottom left (small pan): A light tan with satin to shimmery base and some shimmer particles. It is one shade I did' know how to use. It could make a good subtle contour but it is more shimmery than the other shades. Any ideas here?



Swatch of blush shades from Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette


Below I applied the lightest shade on the inner corner, orangy copper all around the lid, warm bronzy brown at the outer lid and deepest brown at the crease. I lined my eyes with Urban Decay 24/7 in Twice Baked and added Lance Grandiose Mascara on the lashes. 

I found that the eye shadows apply even more beautifully than they swatch. They blend effortlessly but they can still be noticed, meaning they don't over blend. I have tested the eye makeup over 14 hours and it looked freshly applied even after that.



In-action: Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette

Below I have applied the berry shade as a contouring blush, then added a touch of the coral shade on the apples of the cheeks for freshness. I also used the light pink as a highlight by picking it up by a later eye shadow brush (Suqqu Eyeshadow L). On my lips I am wearing Gloss D'Enfer #901 L'Oiseau De Feu (reviewed here).




FOTD with Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette

I also decided to try the look with a edgier lip, below is the same eye placement and blush as above, combined with MAC Matte Lipstick in Styled in Sepia (reviewed here). I know it is not that Guerlain but I think it brings this look more to life.


FOTD: Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette, MAC Styled in Sepia

Now on to comparisons. I have been collecting Guerlain palettes since a few Holiday Collections, so I was curious how similar they are. Below you can see Liu Palette for Eyes and Lips from 2012 and Crazy Paris Eye Palette from last year. First about the package, although I love the eyes colors from Liu Palette, which I keep on wearing because of that one taupe I can't get enough, I am principally not a fan of lip and eye palettes since eye shadows dusts over the lipstick making it turn messy in time. Crazy Paris was really not my favorite palette (hence I have never reviewed it here) because of awkward shade combination of cool and warm shades which doesn't go all that well together and a repetition of copper and gold from the previous year. They both had around 10.2 to 10.5 g of product and a bigger bulkier package.


Guerlain Petrouchka Eyes and Blush Palette is more compact than the other two, takes smaller space and has more products inside, a generous 11.9 g. In terms of design and packaging, it certainly wins the price among the others.


Comparison of Guerlain Holiday Palettes from 2012, 2013 and 2014,  Liu, Crazy Paris and Petrouchka respectively

As far as the uniqueness go, the upper three shades are very similar to other two palettes, copper shade is repetitive all through the years, ivory and gold are also very close to other releases. The bottom two shades are more unique as well as the Guerlain Holiday Palettes go and it has the new blushes to try so it is still justified even if you own the other palettes in my opinion. Finishes of all three palettes are very similar.



Swatches of first three shades from Guerlain Holiday Palettes, Liu, Crazy Paris and Petrouchka

It was a long review, congratulations if you have made it to the bottom. Check out this beautiful movie from Petrouchka Ballet, starts from 30th second. The first theme and the second theme played are so lovely. The whole atmosphere also reminds me of a Christmas market, so fits to the mood.






Final thoughts: This years Eyes & Blush Palette from Guerlain, Petrouchka doesn't disappoint. It manages to fit almost 12 g products in a rather sleek case. All the products are finely milled and apply beautifully. Check out the comparison swatches above if you own one of the previous palettes though since there are similarities. 


What do you think about blush and eye palettes in general? Do you find them useful?



20 comments

  1. I'm actually pretty glad this is at least an all-powder palette! Not sure how often I'd use it if I got it, but it's tempting anyways! I only own one Guerlain blush (Peach Boy), but it is one of the blushes I use the most often. You're right about them not swatching well, but Peach Boy works beautifully on the cheeks and it lasts throughout the day, so who cares how it swatches ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am also all for all-powder palettes!
      I think it is most suited to travel, since it covers you on blush and eyes department at once and it is sleeker than the other two releases. I haven't tried Peach Boy but sounds like your type of shade from the name ;-)

      Delete
  2. I have the Liu palette and it's the first ever item that made me go literally goo goo ga ga. The Paris one didn't do much for me, but I love that Petrouchka is an all powder palette! I'm still deciding whether or not to get this, because these are shades I know I already have in my stash... but it's such a gorgeous palette, I'm torn :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also like Liu more than Paris. I first skipped Paris then I have seen it reduced at some online sale and couldn't resist. This is how I ended up with both. All-powder palette is certainly a winner. I know the feeling, I was also contemplating long time to buy it or not.

      Delete
  3. Oh la la.. Guerlain always make the best packaging/compact, don't they? And I love the colors on you, Sara, so pretty & beautiful -- there's something about it that warms up your whole face. Thanks for a great review/pictures!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Claire,
      you are right about the packaging, it is lovely. I am not sure how that much warmth looks on me but thanks for your kind comment anyway. :-*

      Delete
  4. I don't do combo palettes anymore. As good as they sound in theory, I don't reach for them that often. I think I'm just too picky- if the colours, textures, and performance aren't ALL exactly what I'm looking for then it just gets shoved in the drawer and forgotten about. Or I depot it and toss the non-winners, which sort of defeats the point of purchasing a pretty set like this one in the first place. The shadows in this are pretty but not really speaking to me. The blushers however are gorgeous. I wish they came separately!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Rach,
      I know what you mean, if everything is together, I am also confused. To depot it would be a pity, it is pretty as it is but I know what you mean. I think you should go for singles and duos in this case. A separate blush palette would have been gorgeous! I have seen though they are bringing a gorgeous Meteorites pressed blush for Spring! Something to look forward to.

      Delete
  5. This is my favourite holiday item so far. The design of the palette is really good - I love the matte gold which doesn't show finger marks. The eye colours are a little warmer than I generally prefer but very easy to work with and despite the shimmer surprisingly useable for daytime looks as well as night and the blushes are a revelation to me - my first Guerlain blushes. I prefer having a palette with blush and eye rather than lipgloss, which as you point out quickly becomes gross. Susan, London

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Susan,
      it is the prettiest palette from the holiday collections, also a stand out for me so far. If I didn't have the palettes from last two years, it would be even more of a unique item for my stash but that copper shade being repeated three times on a row makes it less desirable for me. I love the blushes though, they are much better than permanent Guerlain blushes!

      Delete
  6. Wow, this palette really has everything! The pigmentation and shades look beautiful :)

    -Jen

    www.vibrantbeautyblog.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jen,
      you are right, it has everything. If the shades would be a little more unique, it could be the palette of the year or something.

      Delete
  7. Very nice review and those swatches are gorgeous!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi, thank you for the great review. I was really thinking about this pallet.. It looks gorgeous! However, it is a shame that it is so similar to previous palettes. I have Liu palette and I love it! As you mentioned that taupe shade...oh, my. It's my everyday palette.
    tatiana

    ReplyDelete
  9. Gorgeous, gorgeous, gorgeous, both you and the palette! :) I love the 2-tier design and think the colors complement each other really well. Would be a dream palette to have if you like romantic neutrals. I really want to buy it but I just can't stomach the price. T_T

    ReplyDelete
  10. Oh Sara, I wasn't intending to get this at all... as you mentioned, the eyeshadow shades are largely the same as the previous years'. If anything, I was interested in the blush palette below which is something new. Thanks for letting me know they are much more pigmented and softer than previous Guerlain blushes! Now i've really got to go check it out!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I wasn't intending to get this but then I saw it in Sephora yesterday and thought the bottom 2 eyeshadow shades were so beautiful-I checked your blog for a review as if anyone knows their eyeshadows you do! I am still on the fence just because of the bottom layer-I don't think I would use it

    Stacey | Expat Make-Up Addict xx

    ReplyDelete

I love to hear what you think. Fell free to write in English, German or Turkish.

© Color Me Loud